Before 1912, You Carried Your Groceries in Your Arms

Walter Deubener ran a grocery in St. Paul and watched customers buy only as much as they could physically carry. He ran cord through a paper sack, reinforced it, and gave it handles. The first fifty sold out before noon.

By Eleanor Calloway
Before 1912, You Carried Your Groceries in Your Arms (patent US1305198)

US1305198, granted to Walter H. Deubener of St. Paul on May 27, 1919, covers a paper bag with handles — a "shopping bag" — and it exists because Walter Deubener, a grocer in St. Paul, Minnesota, got tired of watching money walk out of his store in customers' overloaded arms.

The paper sack itself was already established; Margaret Knight's machine had been mass- producing flat-bottomed grocery bags since the 1870s. But a paper sack has no handles. You carry it clutched to your chest with both arms, and there is a hard physical limit to how much of it a person can manage. Beyond that limit, a shopper simply stops buying.

Deubener's fix was almost aggressively simple. He and his wife, Lydia, punched holes near the top and bottom of a paper sack and ran a length of cord up through it, across the bottom, and out the other side to form two loops, reinforcing the holes so the cord would not tear out. The resulting bag could carry something like twenty pounds, and it hung from the hand rather than filling the arms.

What happened next

The Deubeners made fifty bags the first morning and offered them at five cents each. They were gone before noon. With handles, customers could carry substantially more, and the logic of the store changed with it: they could buy more, because the constraint that had been quietly capping every transaction was gone.

The couple sold the store and went into the bag business full time, and by the account usually given they were selling more than a million a year by 1915. The patent came later: he filed in November 1918, and it was granted in May 1919. The design spread rapidly through American retail.

The economics hidden in a handle

The shopping bag belongs to a small category of inventions that changed commerce by changing what a human body can do in a store. It sits alongside Sylvan Goldman's shopping cart, which solved the same problem two decades later at larger scale and for the same reason. In both cases the invention is trivial mechanically — a cord, a wheeled frame — and the insight is behavioral: people buy exactly as much as they can carry, and no more.

Every element of modern retail that assumes a customer can accumulate a large basket of goods before paying descends from that observation. So does the entire visual grammar of the paper shopping bag with rope handles, which retail turned from a convenience into a status object — printed, branded, and carried down the street as advertising.

The bag in your hand at the end of a shopping trip is one of the oldest pieces of conversion-rate optimization in existence. It was invented by a grocer who could see, from behind his own counter, exactly how much business two full arms were costing him.

See the original

The full text and figures of US1305198 are on Google Patents.

Patent drawing by Walter H. Deubener for "Walter h", U.S. Patent 1,305,198 (1919)
Sheet 1 of 1 of the drawings for U.S. Patent 1,305,198, Walter h, by Walter H. Deubener, issued May 27, 1919. Public domain. Read the full patent on Google Patents →

Related stories