It Took Decades to Figure Out That the Staples Should Come in a Glued Strip

The first successful stapler held one staple at a time. You loaded it, squeezed, and reloaded. Magazine machines followed, but feeding loose or wire-linked staples was fiddly. The lasting fix was gluing the staples together into a strip.

By Marcus Feld
It Took Decades to Figure Out That the Staples Should Come in a Glued Strip (patent US212316)

US212316 was filed on January 9, 1879, and granted to George W. McGill of New York on February 18, 1879. The title is "Improvement in Devices for Inserting Metallic Staples in Papers, &c." It is the McGill Single-Stroke Staple Press, usually called the first commercially successful stapler. McGill had been working on binding paper with metal since his bendable brass fastener of 1866, and his machines are among the ancestors of the object on your desk.

They also had a defect that took decades to fix properly, and the lasting fix was not mechanical.

One at a time

McGill's stapler held a single staple, a half-inch length of wire. You placed it in the machine, pressed the handle to drive it through the paper, and then loaded the next one by hand.

This is not a small inconvenience. For an office binding hundreds of documents a day, the loading motion dominates the task entirely. The actual stapling takes a moment; the reloading takes several.

Inventors attacked it from many directions. Magazine machines that held a supply of staples appeared early; the Hotchkiss No. 1 of 1895 fed staples joined in a strip, and others cut and formed staples from a coil of wire. The patent record through the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries is full of ingenious staplers with improved levers, better anvils and cleverer feeds, but loading them was fiddly, because loose staples do not stack neatly in a channel.

Gluing the ammunition

The lasting fix, which arrived in the mid-1920s, was to change the staples rather than the machine: manufacture them in a long strip, held together side by side with a thin adhesive. The Boston Wire Stitcher Company, later Bostitch, filed for cemented strips in 1925 and for strips held by glue alone in 1929.

A glued strip is rigid enough to sit in a spring-loaded magazine and advance reliably, and weak enough that the driver blade shears off exactly one staple per stroke. Suddenly a stapler could hold two hundred staples, and the reload became a once-a-week event instead of a once-a-document one.

Everything people think of as "the stapler" — the flat magazine, the spring, the satisfying single-stroke action — depends on that consumable innovation, not on the press.

Why it is a good lesson

The stapler is a clean case of a category-wide blind spot. For decades, much of the inventive effort went into the durable machine while the real constraint sat in the disposable part.

It also produced a second-order effect familiar from the razor and the bottle cap: once the staples were a proprietary consumable strip, the business shifted from selling staplers to selling staples, and manufacturers had a strong interest in strip formats that fit their own machines.

The modern desk stapler has barely changed since the 1930s. It is one of those objects that reached its final form early and simply stopped, because there is nothing left in it worth improving.

See the original

The full text and figures of US212316 are on Google Patents.

Patent drawing by George W. McGill for "Improvement in devices for inserting metallic staples in papers", U.S. Patent 212,316 (1879)
Sheet 1 of 4 of the drawings for U.S. Patent 212,316, Improvement in devices for inserting metallic staples in papers, by George W. McGill, issued February 18, 1879. Public domain. Read the full patent on Google Patents →

Related stories