The Ice Cream Cone Has at Least Five Claimed Inventors and One Very Convenient Legend

The story says a waffle vendor at the 1904 St. Louis World's Fair rescued a neighboring ice cream seller who ran out of dishes. It is a wonderful story. It is also contradicted by a patent filed in New York the year before.

By Marcus Feld
The Ice Cream Cone Has at Least Five Claimed Inventors and One Very Convenient Legend (patent US746971)

US746971 was filed on September 22, 1903, and granted to Italo Marchiony of New York on December 15, 1903, under the plain title "Mold." It is one of several patents in the cone's tangled history, and it is the one that does the most damage to the best-known version of the story, because it was granted the year before that story is supposed to have happened.

The popular story is fixed and charming. At the 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition in St. Louis — the World's Fair — an ice cream vendor ran out of paper dishes on a hot day. A Syrian immigrant named Ernest Hamwi, selling a crisp waffle pastry called zalabis at the next stall, rolled one of his wafers into a cone, handed it over, and the ice cream cone was born.

It is a good story: immigrant ingenuity, a hot afternoon, a happy accident, an American icon. It is still the version most people know.

The trouble with it

The trouble is that the cone predates the fair.

In 1903, a year before St. Louis, Italo Marchiony — an Italian immigrant selling ice cream from a pushcart in New York City — was granted a patent for a mold to make edible ice cream cups with a small handle, formed from a prepared paste in a hinged, waffle-iron-like device. He had reportedly been selling ice cream in edible pastry cups on the streets of New York since the 1890s, driven by a very practical problem: customers kept walking off with, or breaking, his glass serving dishes.

Earlier still, edible cones and rolled wafers served with ice cream appear in European cookbooks and illustrations going back into the nineteenth century. The idea of putting ice cream into something you could eat was not a bolt from the blue in 1904.

What likely did happen at St. Louis is that the cone met the American mass public. The fair drew roughly twenty million visitors, and multiple vendors there — Hamwi among several others who later claimed credit, including David Avayou and Abe Doumar — were selling ice cream in rolled waffles. The exposure turned a local curiosity into a national habit.

Why it stays contested

At least five people have been credited as the cone's inventor at various points, and the records genuinely conflict. Patents exist for molds and rolling machines from several inventors across a decade. Newspaper accounts from the fair are inconsistent. Family claims, understandably, are firm.

The honest summary is the one this archive keeps arriving at: popular objects rarely have a single inventor. They have a slow accumulation of people solving the same problem, one of whom happens to be standing in the right place when the public shows up.

The 1904 fair is not where the ice cream cone was invented. It is where it was discovered — by everybody at once, which is a different and in some ways more important event.

See the original

The full text and figures of US746971 are on Google Patents.

Patent drawing by Italo Marchiony for "Mold", U.S. Patent 746,971 (1903)
Sheet 1 of 1 of the drawings for U.S. Patent 746,971, Mold, by Italo Marchiony, issued December 15, 1903. Public domain. Read the full patent on Google Patents →

Related stories