In 1896 a Man From Spokane Patented a Hat That Tipped Itself When You Bowed

Raising your hat to a lady was basic manners in the 1890s, and it took a free hand. James C. Boyle's clockwork saluting device lifted the hat, spun it and put it back down every time the wearer nodded. He also suggested it would make a fine advertisement.

By Eleanor Calloway
In 1896 a Man From Spokane Patented a Hat That Tipped Itself When You Bowed (patent US556248)

US556248 was filed on September 18, 1895, and granted on March 10, 1896, to James C. Boyle of Spokane, Washington, who assigned half of it to John Neill of the same city. The title is "Saluting Device."

Its purpose, in the patent's words, is "automatically effecting polite salutations by the elevation and rotation of the hat on the head of the saluting party when said person bows to the person or persons saluted," and all of it is done "without the use of the hands in any manner."

The problem

A gentleman of the period raised his hat to greet a woman, or anyone he wished to honor. It was a small, constant duty, and it needed a free hand. Anyone carrying parcels, an umbrella or a small child had a social problem.

The machine in the hat

Boyle's answer fits entirely inside the hat, hidden by it. A case holding the mechanism is attached to the wearer's head by curved spring fingers that gently clasp the skull. A coiled spring, wound in advance like a clock, supplies the power. A curved bow-piece clips onto the hat itself.

The trigger is the bow. When the wearer nods, a weighted block swings and releases the mechanism. The device lifts the hat, rotates it completely, and sets it back down correctly on the head every time the wearer bows and stands up straight again. A small check-block can be set to stop it working, for times when you would rather not salute anyone.

The second use

Boyle had a commercial afterthought, and it may be the most sensible line in the patent. The device, he wrote, "is also available as a unique and attractive advertising medium." Put a sign or placard on the hat, walk down a crowded street, and the novelty of a hat that moves by itself will draw every eye to it.

What became of it

There is no sign that anyone bought one. Hat-tipping faded in the twentieth century, along with the hats themselves, and the saluting device became a favorite of collections of strange patents.

It is easy to laugh at, and still oddly reasonable. Boyle saw a real, everyday inconvenience, worked out a mechanism that could actually do the job, and spotted the marketing angle as well. The only thing he misjudged was whether anyone wanted clockwork strapped to their head.

See the original

The full text and figures of US556248 are on Google Patents.

Patent drawing by James C. Boyle for "Saluting Device", U.S. Patent 556,248 (1896)
Sheet 1 of 2 of the drawings for U.S. Patent 556,248, Saluting Device, by James C. Boyle, issued March 10, 1896. Public domain. Read the full patent on Google Patents →

Related stories