Silly Putty Was a Wartime Attempt to Replace Rubber. It Failed at Everything Except Bouncing.

Japan captured the rubber-producing regions of Asia and the United States needed a synthetic substitute urgently. A General Electric chemist dropped boric acid into silicone oil and got a substance that stretched, snapped, bounced, and was useless for tires.

By Marcus Feld
Silly Putty Was a Wartime Attempt to Replace Rubber. It Failed at Everything Except Bouncing. (patent US2431878)

US2431878 was filed on March 30, 1943, and granted on December 2, 1947, to Rob Roy McGregor and Earl L. Warrick, and assigned to Corning Glass Works. The title is "Treating Dimethyl Silicone Polymer with Boric Oxide," and the bouncing putty it describes is the stuff the world knows as Silly Putty. Who invented it first is disputed: General Electric's James Wright arrived at the same material the same year, and Warrick insisted for the rest of his life that his team got there first. Either way, it exists because of a genuine strategic emergency.

After Pearl Harbor, Japanese forces took control of the rubber-producing regions of Southeast Asia, cutting the Allies off from most of the world's natural rubber supply. Rubber was not a convenience; it was tires, boots, gaskets, hoses, and aircraft parts. The United States government poured funding into finding a synthetic replacement, and laboratories across the country went to work on it.

At General Electric's laboratory in New Haven, James Wright, working on silicone chemistry, combined boric acid with silicone oil, in the version of the story most often told. The result was a substance nobody quite expected.

A material with contradictory manners

The putty is a non-Newtonian material, which means its behavior depends entirely on how fast you deform it.

Pull it slowly and it stretches like taffy, indefinitely. Yank it sharply and it snaps clean, like a brittle solid. Roll it into a ball and drop it and it bounces higher than rubber. Leave it sitting on a table and it slowly flows into a puddle, like a very thick liquid. Strike it with a hammer and it can shatter.

It also had a party trick that defined its early reputation: pressed onto newsprint, it lifts a mirror-image copy of the ink.

As a rubber substitute it was a complete failure. It could not hold a shape under load, it had no structural strength, and no one could find a serious industrial use for it. GE sent samples to engineers around the world asking for suggestions. Nobody had any.

Peter Hodgson

The putty circulated for several years as a laboratory curiosity and party novelty. In 1949 a toy store owner, Ruth Fallgatter, came across it and brought in a marketing consultant, Peter Hodgson, who recognized what everyone else had missed: the uselessness was the product. People could not stop playing with it.

He borrowed $147, bought a batch, and packaged it in small plastic eggs — a decision made partly because Easter was approaching and partly because the eggs were cheap and the right size. He named it Silly Putty.

A New Yorker mention in 1950 produced a flood of orders. Silly Putty went on to sell in the hundreds of millions of units.

Where it ended up

Its afterlife is oddly distinguished. Apollo 8 astronauts reportedly carried it to secure tools in zero gravity. Physical therapists use it for hand-strength rehabilitation. Physics classrooms use it to demonstrate viscoelasticity, because there is no better five-second illustration that "solid" and "liquid" are not always distinct categories.

The wartime program that funded it did eventually produce real synthetic rubber, through entirely different chemistry. Silly Putty contributed nothing to the war effort at all — it is one of the most commercially successful research failures in American history.

See the original

The full text of US2431878 is on Google Patents.

Related stories

Mary Kenner Designed a Sanitary Belt in the 1920s. A Company Dropped It When It Learned She Was Black.

Mary Kenner Designed a Sanitary Belt in the 1920s. A Company Dropped It When It Learned She Was Black.

Mary Beatrice Davidson Kenner came up with an adjustable sanitary belt as a young woman and could not afford to patent it for 30 years. When a company finally showed interest, it walked away on learning she was Black. She went on to earn five patents while working as a florist.

Read the story →
The Man Who Patented the Pringles Can Was Buried in One

The Man Who Patented the Pringles Can Was Buried in One

Procter & Gamble chemist Fredric Baur was asked to fix the potato chip bag: too much air, too many broken chips. His answer was a stack of identical saddle-shaped crisps in a sealed tube. When he died in 2008, his family put part of his ashes in one.

Read the story →
Twister's Patent Is Titled 'Apparatus for Playing a Game Wherein the Players Constitute the Game Pieces'

Twister's Patent Is Titled 'Apparatus for Playing a Game Wherein the Players Constitute the Game Pieces'

The patent title is the whole idea: the people are the pieces. Milton Bradley released the game in 1966, some retailers were wary of it, and critics found it a little too intimate. Then Johnny Carson played it on television with Eva Gabor, and the orders poured in.

Read the story →
Ernő Rubik Needed About a Month to Solve His Own Cube. An American Court Later Found It Infringed an Earlier US Patent.

Ernő Rubik Needed About a Month to Solve His Own Cube. An American Court Later Found It Infringed an Earlier US Patent.

Rubik built the first cube in Budapest in 1974 as a way to think about three-dimensional movement. The clever part is how it holds together when most of its pieces are not attached to anything. In the United States, a chemist named Larry Nichols had patented a related puzzle in 1972, and his company sued.

Read the story →