Carpenters Sharpened Pencils With a Knife. John Lee Love Put the Blade in a Box.

Desk-mounted crank sharpeners existed by the 1890s, but they were furniture. Most people still shaved a point with a knife. Love built a small sharpener that needed no mounting, caught its own shavings, and doubled as a paperweight.

By Eleanor Calloway
Carpenters Sharpened Pencils With a Knife. John Lee Love Put the Blade in a Box. (patent US594114)

US594114 was filed on April 23, 1897, and granted to John Lee Love on November 23, 1897, for a portable pencil sharpener. It is usually called the Love Sharpener.

Love was a Black inventor working as a carpenter in Fall River, Massachusetts. He held at least two patents, and the other one, for an improved plasterer's hawk, tells you the same thing about him: these are tools designed by someone who used tools all day.

Two kinds of sharpener

Mechanical pencil sharpeners existed before 1897. The good ones were large crank-operated machines bolted to a desk or a wall, with planetary cutters that produced an excellent point. Schools and offices had them.

That does no good on a job site. A carpenter marking cuts needs a sharp pencil constantly, and the standard method was to take out a pocket knife and whittle the point, which takes both hands, produces an uneven point, wastes pencil, and occasionally produces a cut finger.

Love's patent targets that gap. The device is small, requires no mounting, and is simple: put the pencil in the conical opening and turn it against a blade set in one side. The patent also suggests a second life for it on the desk, as a paperweight or ornament, made as decorative as the owner likes.

The shavings

The feature that separates his design from a bare blade is the receptacle. The sharpener captures the shavings inside the body instead of dropping them wherever the user is standing.

It is the reason a sharpener can sit on a desk, which is where Love himself pictured it. Nearly every handheld sharpener sold since has the same arrangement: a blade over a tapered hole, and a sealed chamber underneath with a lid.

The mechanism is so simple that it has resisted improvement for more than a century. The plastic sharpener in a school pencil case is Love's design in a cheaper material.

What is recorded

Details of Love's life are sparse and the dates in circulation conflict with each other. He is generally recorded as born in North Carolina and working in Fall River, Massachusetts, and he died in 1931. Beyond that the documentation is thin, which is the usual situation for Black inventors of the period, whose lives were recorded in municipal directories rather than in newspapers.

The patent office kept his drawing.

See the original

The full text and figures of US594114 are on Google Patents.

Patent drawing by John Lee Love for "Pencil-sharpener", U.S. Patent 594,114 (1897)
Sheet 1 of 1 of the drawings for U.S. Patent 594,114, Pencil-sharpener, by John Lee Love, issued November 23, 1897. Public domain. Read the full patent on Google Patents →

Related stories