The Supreme Court Invalidated the Pencil-With-an-Eraser Patent, and Set a Rule Still Used Today
Hymen Lipman patented sticking an eraser on the end of a pencil in 1858 and sold the rights for a fortune. The Supreme Court threw the patent out, ruling that combining two known things that each keep doing their own job is not an invention.

US19783 was granted to Hymen L. Lipman of Philadelphia on March 30, 1858. The title is "Combination of Lead-Pencil and Eraser," and it is the ancestor of the object sitting in every desk drawer in America: one pencil that both writes and erases. It is also one of the most consequential invalidated patents in United States law.
Pencils existed. Rubber erasers existed, and had since the 1770s, when it was discovered that a lump of caoutchouc would rub out graphite marks, which is where the word "rubber" comes from. What Lipman claimed was the combination. He made the pencil in the usual way but reserved about a quarter of its length, cut a groove there, and glued in a strip of prepared india-rubber before finishing the wood. Sharpen one end and you had the lead; sharpen the other and you had a point of rubber, fine enough to erase between closely drawn lines. His patent even says he did not claim simply attaching rubber to the end of a pencil.
In 1862 Lipman sold the patent to a businessman named Joseph Reckendorfer for a reported one hundred thousand dollars — an enormous sum for the era.
Reckendorfer v. Faber
Reckendorfer then sued the pencil manufacturer Eberhard Faber for infringement, and in 1875 the case reached the Supreme Court of the United States.
The Court invalidated the patent, and its reasoning is the part that outlived the pencil. The justices held that a mere aggregation of two known devices, where each continues to perform its own familiar function and nothing new emerges from the pairing, is not patentable.
The pencil still wrote exactly as pencils write. The eraser still erased exactly as erasers erase. Putting them at opposite ends of the same stick was convenient, but the combination produced no new effect and required no inventive leap. A combination is patentable, the Court held in substance, only when the parts together produce a new and useful result — not merely when they are found in the same place.
Reckendorfer lost his hundred thousand dollars.
Why it still matters
Reckendorfer v. Faber remains a foundational American case on the difference between an invention and a mere aggregation. The same question, whether bolting two known things together is an invention, keeps coming back, from mechanical cases to modern software and business-method patents.
The irony is durable. The pencil-with-eraser turned out to be enormously useful and completely ubiquitous. Its usefulness was never in question. What the Court decided was that being useful and being inventive are different tests, and that the patent system only rewards the second one.
Every combination patent argued since has, somewhere in its lineage, a Philadelphia stationer who glued an eraser onto a pencil and briefly became rich.
See the original
The full text and figures of US19783 are on Google Patents.

Related stories

Mark Twain Patented a Strap to Replace Suspenders. He Thought Its Advantages Needed No Explanation.
In 1871 Samuel Clemens of Hartford patented an elastic strap that buttoned onto a vest or trousers and moved from one garment to the next. It was the first of his three patents. The story that it became the bra strap is mostly folklore.
Read the story →
Mary Kenner Designed a Sanitary Belt in the 1920s. A Company Dropped It When It Learned She Was Black.
Mary Beatrice Davidson Kenner came up with an adjustable sanitary belt as a young woman and could not afford to patent it for 30 years. When a company finally showed interest, it walked away on learning she was Black. She went on to earn five patents while working as a florist.
Read the story →
The Man Who Patented the Pringles Can Was Buried in One
Procter & Gamble chemist Fredric Baur was asked to fix the potato chip bag: too much air, too many broken chips. His answer was a stack of identical saddle-shaped crisps in a sealed tube. When he died in 2008, his family put part of his ashes in one.
Read the story →
Twister's Patent Is Titled 'Apparatus for Playing a Game Wherein the Players Constitute the Game Pieces'
The patent title is the whole idea: the people are the pieces. Milton Bradley released the game in 1966, some retailers were wary of it, and critics found it a little too intimate. Then Johnny Carson played it on television with Eva Gabor, and the orders poured in.
Read the story →